Top 10 Releases


Author
Message
User avatar
Mr_Neffets


User avatar

Joined: Fri Sep 16, 2016 2:37 am
Favorite Pokemon: bulbasaur

Post Posted:

I'm cheating because no one can stop me and I'm putting 15. More so I wanted to keep going past 10 because it was interesting to just see my gut ranking and how I compared things. But not like this is such a hard ranking. Also way too early for me to throw Time Skiffs in, but I think it'll make the list.

Random thoughts as I think about the album while being very tired.

1. Feels
This is probably my favorite production on any album ever. Like wet, and everything feels natural. This to me is their true middle ground between the two prime eras of the band. Loch Raven and Banshee Beat are unbeatable.

2. Fall Be Kind
Reminds me of walking around my college campus at night in the winter. "What's in the way??" is one of my favorite musical moments ever.

3. Merriweather Post Pavilion
My first anco release. Captures a sort of reverence and gratitude for life and probably has the best melodies in their discography. Taste is also unbeatable. Wish they would do more of that kind of two vocal lines at once.

4. Sung Tongs
The Softest Voice is sacred. Vocals are perfect.

5. Strawberry Jam
Kinda tied in my mind with Feels as the most quintessential album that showcases what makes the band special but still falls in the "modern" era for me. But this is saturated while Feels is natural, which isn't a bad or good thing. I don't know of any other artist that can scream like they do on this but have it be so beautiful.

6. Spirit They’re Gone
This album is saturated with young, naive talent. Second half of Bat You'll Fly is so good. This album made me think of the role of percussion entirely differently in music.

7. Water Curses
If I can include Safer in here then yeah I'll do that too haha. Street Flash is so wonderful and juicy

8. Person Pitch
I'm not.

9. Pullhair Rubeye (Reversed)
This makes me sad in a beautiful way when I listen to it.

10. Sleep Cycle
Golden Chords stands with the groups best.

11. Tomboy
For whatever reason, I like this more and more each year. Has a classic vibe to it even though I usually don't point to specific stand out songs.

12. Centipede Hz
Burritos are one of my favorite foods actually.

13. Campfire Songs
Two Corvettes 1:30 to 2:20 is one of the best vocal harmony melodies ever created. Soto De Son is perfect.

14. Painting With
I love the hocketing actually. Super fun w/ headphones. They just needed to chop off splling guts and summing the wretch. Fart synths can be fun every now and then.

15. Ark
I actually like this and Hollindagin a lot, but rarely listen to them. So I have a hard time gut ranking them higher, but this has a core sound to the band that is very special to me, and quintessentially them. But like I need to be alone and just sitting there to really get into it.
Profile Quote
User avatar
sky crawler
 
 


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 3:37 pm
Favorite Pokemon: Wartortle

Post Posted:

this is hard

1. MPP
2. Ark
3. Strawberry
4. Feels
5. Down There
6. Person Pitch
7. Painting With
8. Water Curses + Safer (other people cheated so I will too)
9. Fall Be Kind
10. Sung Tongs


felt really bad leaving Campfire, Day with the Homies, and Prospect Hummer off

damn what a band :')
Profile Quote
User avatar
MFpotus


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 4:43 am

Post Posted:

1. Centipede Hz
2. Feels
3. Sung Tongs
4. Water Curses
5. Honeycomb/Gotham
6. Fall Be Kind
7. MPP
8. Campfire Songs
9. Cows On Hourglass Pond
10. Mr Noah

too early to include Time Skiffs
Profile Quote
User avatar
Stan


User avatar

Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2017 1:59 pm

Post Posted:

Wow good job the awards dried up buddy
Profile Quote
User avatar
headroom)))


User avatar

Joined: Fri Mar 08, 2019 6:52 am

Post Posted:

Paste Magazine getting in on the ranking game
https://www.pastemagazine.com/music/ani ... me-skiffs/
Profile Quote
User avatar
rohcti


User avatar

Joined: Thu Mar 27, 2014 5:31 am
Location: forever at the push of a button

Post Posted:

MFpotus wrote:
1. Centipede Hz
2. Feels
3. Sung Tongs
4. Water Curses
5. Honeycomb/Gotham
6. Fall Be Kind
7. MPP
8. Campfire Songs
9. Cows On Hourglass Pond
10. Mr Noah

too early to include Time Skiffs

Great list, some interesting choices. Just curious, why Cows over Eucalyptus or Down There?
Profile Quote
User avatar
blindmowing


User avatar

Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2015 5:36 am

Post Posted:

Updated Rankings as tallied from all submissions:

200 CLUB
1. Feels - 255
2. Strawberry Jam - 223

100 CLUB
3. MPP - 196
4. Sung Tongs - 184
5. Person Pitch - 174
6. Water Curses - 100

7. Spirit - 97
8. Ark - 93
9. Fall Be Kind - 71
10. ODDSAC - 42


Most 1st Places:
1. Feels - 9
2. MPP - 6
2. Sung Tongs - 6
4. Jam - 4
5. Water Curses - 3
Profile Quote
User avatar
tay's tee games


User avatar

Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2022 11:46 pm

Post Posted:

1. Feels
2. MPP
3. Water Curses + Safer
4. Strawberry Jam
5. Sung Tongs
6. FBK
7. Homies
8. Spirit
9. Prospect Hummer
10. Cows

A few shout-outs:

Ark - to me their most cohesive but such a specific mood that I don't often come back to it
Honeycomb/Gotham - would be easily top 5 for me if it wasn't just two songs
Skiffs - too soon to call really but also feels like 90% of my fav songs of this era are on LP/EP2
Campfire - top tier for me but I find it impossible to listen to individual songs from it, so come back to it less than others
Eucalyptus - one of the most emotionally potent bodies of work for me but feels like there was fat to trip
PP/PBVGR/Tomboy - the highlights are better than anything ever but the duds are so dud-y
_________________
unrecordednight wrote:
just piss yourself cowards

Profile Quote
User avatar
MFpotus


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 4:43 am

Post Posted:

rohcti wrote:
MFpotus wrote:
Spoiler: show
1. Centipede Hz
2. Feels
3. Sung Tongs
4. Water Curses
5. Honeycomb/Gotham
6. Fall Be Kind
7. MPP
8. Campfire Songs
9. Cows On Hourglass Pond
10. Mr Noah

too early to include Time Skiffs

Great list, some interesting choices. Just curious, why Cows over Eucalyptus or Down There?

Aha thanks. Was going through some stuff when Cows came out and Whats the Goodside helped me in a big way. I also saw him perform these songs with Deakin and Jeremy Hyman. Holds a special place in my heart.

Don't like the idea of ranking them. #1 could be different on any given day. But someone had to stick up for CHz!!
Profile Quote
User avatar
MFpotus


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 4:43 am

Post Posted:

Stan wrote:
Wow good job the awards dried up buddy

this post is my award <3
Profile Quote
User avatar
Stan


User avatar

Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2017 1:59 pm

Post Posted:

:laugh:
Profile Quote
User avatar
febbecool


User avatar

Joined: Thu Sep 30, 2021 10:18 am
Favorite Pokemon: Umbreon

Post Posted:

1. A Day with the Homies
2. Sung Tongs
3. Buoys
4. Person Pitch
5. Feels
6. SJ
7. MPP
8. The Painters
9. Prospect Hummer
10. Pullhair (In the way you can actually hear what they're singing)
Profile Quote
User avatar
sky crawler
 
 


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 3:37 pm
Favorite Pokemon: Wartortle

Post Posted:

sky crawler wrote:
this is hard

1. MPP
2. Ark
3. Strawberry
4. Feels
5. Down There
6. Person Pitch
7. Painting With
8. Water Curses + Safer (other people cheated so I will too)
9. Fall Be Kind
10. Sung Tongs


felt really bad leaving Campfire, Day with the Homies, and Prospect Hummer off

damn what a band :')

Been listening to a lot of AC lately after not really clicking with Skiffs and being off the band for a while. Updated list:

1. Strawberry Jam
2. Ark
3. Person Pitch
4. MPP
5. Painting With
6. Feels
7. Sung Tongs
8. Down There
9. Day with the Homies
10. Fall be Kind

If I exclude the EPs:

9. Tomboy
10. Buoys
Profile Quote
User avatar
Hellomark


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 5:05 am
Location: unnecessary surgery land

Post Posted:

Always fun to give this question another go every once in awhile

1 feels
2 sj
3 mpp
4 water curses
5 ark
6 person pitch
7 spirit
8 sung tongs
9 fbk
10 down there
Profile Quote
User avatar
nothingmaster


User avatar

Joined: Sat Nov 02, 2019 5:05 pm

Post Posted:

1. feels
this was the band's peak
2. campfire
my first love. I didn't know there could be music like this. their most "magical" project
3. sung tongs
it's just excellent.
4. person pitch
grew on me a ton over the years. leaves me feeling light as a sunbeam
5. water curses
impeccably tight project, a brief sub-era that I wish had more representation. while I love that ODDSAC happened, some of the songs on there with water curses stuff would make a stupendous album
5. eucalyptus
a chilled out, trippy and odd journey. I love all the samples and arrangements on this record. perfect rainy day listen
6. ark
an incredible, cathartic trip into the darkness. can't do this one too often because Panic makes me want to run away sometimes
7. time skiffs
it's timeless. I love how hi-fi this album is. I just love the sonics and I love how distinct each song is
8. strawberry
I love this era but this album feels to me a bit more disjointed than the really cohesive journeys I love in the top 5. the songs on the album carried this into the top 10
9. mpp
10. down there
Profile Quote
User avatar
preakness


User avatar

Joined: Wed Jun 14, 2017 5:38 pm
Location: new york

Post Posted:

My picks usually change but i'll try to list what generally I would say is the case.

The official Preakness Choice Awards 2022 top 10 lineup:

1. Person Pitch
2. Sung Tongs
3. Feels
4. Strawberry Jam
5. Tomboy
6. Fall Be Kind
7. MPP
8. PBVSGR
9. Eucalyptus
10. Campfire Songs

I love seeing so many people with ST and PP so high on the list. Definitely agree more with the lists here than anything ive seen on reddit, 4chan, etc. Yall get it lol
Profile Quote
User avatar
andthephantom


User avatar

Joined: Fri Jul 15, 2022 12:01 am

Post Posted:

I'm gonna list the top 10 based on estimated listens - which somehow isn't the same as enjoyment.

1 Sung Tongs
2 Strawberry Jam
3 Water Curses
4 A Day With the Homies
5 Person Pitch
6 Fall Be Kind
7 Spirit
8 Feels
9 Painting With
10 Conference of Birds / Birds in Disguise tied with Pullhair Rubeye (legible version)

Too early to put Skiffs or Reset up there. But I think both are coming . . .
Profile Quote
User avatar
ingenue


User avatar

Joined: Mon Feb 22, 2016 2:24 am
Location: Off-world

Post Posted:

1 Sung Tongs
2 Down There
3 Feels
4 Young Prayer
5 MPP
6 PBVSGR
7 Buoys
8 Prospect Hummer
9 Strawberry Jam
10 Pullhair Rubeye (forward version)
Profile Quote
User avatar
preakness


User avatar

Joined: Wed Jun 14, 2017 5:38 pm
Location: new york

Post Posted:

Could also be cool to see y'all's top 10 songs? A bit more challenging but could be cool to see.

1. Bros
2. Tikwid
3. Prospect Hummer
4. Fireworks
5. Alvin
6. Cobwebs
7. WWIWS
8. The Preakness (duh)
9. Winters Love
10. #1 tie w Loch Raven
Profile Quote
User avatar
scrambledgreggs


User avatar

Joined: Fri Jun 05, 2015 9:30 pm
Favorite Pokemon: Togekiss
Location: Seattle

Post Posted:

oi so difficult but

1. The Purple Bottle
2. Safer
3. Too Soon
4. Bros
5. For Reverend Green
6. Banshee Beat
7. Peacebone
8. Infant Dressing Table
9. I Remember Learning How To Dive
10. Pride & Fight
_________________
art / bandcamp / rym
Profile Quote
User avatar
preakness


User avatar

Joined: Wed Jun 14, 2017 5:38 pm
Location: new york

Post Posted:

scrambledgreggs wrote:
oi so difficult but

1. The Purple Bottle
2. Safer
3. Too Soon
4. Bros
5. For Reverend Green
6. Banshee Beat
7. Peacebone
8. Infant Dressing Table
9. I Remember Learning How To Dive
10. Pride & Fight

Yeah i may have spoke too soon, safer def replaces something on mine. Infant Dressing Table and Pride are some of my absolute favs from the early days
Profile Quote
User avatar
Stan


User avatar

Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2017 1:59 pm

Post Posted:

1. Banshee Beat
2. House
3. Street Flash
4. Lablakely Dress
5. Alvin Row
6. Did You See The Words
7. Bros
8. Loch Raven
9. Pride & Fight
10. Prospect Hummer

I'm staggered that I can't find a place for Infant Dressing Table, Essplode, Daily Routine and so so many more.
Profile Quote
User avatar
Hellomark


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 5:05 am
Location: unnecessary surgery land

Post Posted:

Can't put them in order, but basically these are all tied for #1

Fireworks
Safer
Street Flash
Infant Dressing Table
WWIW?S
DYSTW?
Derek
Alvin Row
Brother Sport
Turn Into Something
Profile Quote
User avatar
blindmowing


User avatar

Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2015 5:36 am

Post Posted:

Banshee Beat
Loch Raven
Bros
WCWAR
WWIW?S
Taste
For Reverend Green
Chocolate Girl
Comfy in Nautica
Last Night at the Jetty
Profile Quote
User avatar
unrecordednight


User avatar

Joined: Thu Oct 07, 2021 9:25 pm

Post Posted:

penny dreadfuls
i see you pan
de soto de son
winters love
wastered
mercury man
strung with everything
island chase
slow words
untitled 3 - young prayer
Profile Quote
User avatar
tay's tee games


User avatar

Joined: Sun Jan 30, 2022 11:46 pm

Post Posted:

Nah I mean this is impossible and quite silly really. It'll change almost daily and there's no way to order it properly but these would always rotate in the top 20 at least... Making a top 25 would be very difficult but doable.

Banshee Beat
Defeat
Did You See The Words
Taste
College
Derek
Cobwebs
Cuckoo Cuckoo
Gotham
Alvin Row

I realise that's pretty Panda-thin but the next ten would be very Panda and early stuff heavy. Weirdly I also sort of feel that the strongest solo songs aren't anywhere near as strong as the strongest band songs. Especially Avey's stuff. But my top 10 solo songs is relatively easy to define:

Last Night at the Jetty
Selfish Gene
Sunset
Laughing Hieroglyphic
Country Report
The Preakness
Remember Mayan
Part of the Math
Dolphin
What's the Goodside?
_________________
unrecordednight wrote:
just piss yourself cowards

Profile Quote
User avatar
nickinko


User avatar

Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2016 11:37 am

Post Posted:

Bros
Bees
Also Frightened
For Reverend Green
You Can Count On Me
Loch Raven
Mr Noah
No More Runnin
In My Body
Today's Supernatural
Profile Quote
User avatar
sky crawler
 
 


User avatar

Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 3:37 pm
Favorite Pokemon: Wartortle

Post Posted:

well this is impossible

Safer
Bros
Also Frightened
Lying in the Grass
Mountain Game
Loch Raven
Winter's Love
Heads Hammock
Two Sails on a Sound
I Think I Can

not having a single song from my favorite album is so crazy but here we are lol
Profile Quote
User avatar
febbecool


User avatar

Joined: Thu Sep 30, 2021 10:18 am
Favorite Pokemon: Umbreon

Post Posted:

1. Brother Sport
2. Safer
3. Kinda Bonkers
4. Prospect Hummer
5. Visiting Friends
6. Grass
7. #1
8. Rosie Oh
9. Winters Love
10. Wide Eyed
11. Slippi
12. My Girls
13. Hocus Pocus
14. New Town Burnout
15. I Remember Learning how to Dive
16. Who Could Win A Rabbit
17. Bees
18. The Purple Bottle
19. Doggy
20. Chocolate Girl
Profile Quote
REPLY New Topic

All times are UTC



You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum