Wow, excellent first post HZvalentine and welcome to the forum! I don't think I could have put it better myself, especially this part:
HZvalentine wrote:
I don't think 'perfect' exists in any sense of reality - but in the moment in the studio where he said 'it's done', he saw it as perfect and complete as it could be. We have to respect that decision - it won't change and it's done.
I think the problem with those of us who listened extensively to bootlegs (and I'd count myself among those people) is that we feel like we own these songs. After all, not many people knew about them for a long time, so it felt like we were in on something exclusive. And in addition to that, we got so accustomed to hearing certain versions of the songs to the point that it felt like they were practically tailored to our personal tastes and preferences.
It's cliché, but it makes me think of this platitude: If you love something, set it free. I think to really enjoy this album, you need to set this it free, so to speak. Let it be what it's supposed to be, and what Panda Bear intended it to be, instead of what
you want it to be, and the album quickly reveals itself as an unprecedented masterpiece.
To think that PB simply overlooked the possibility of including the drops, or any other detail for that matter, is absurd in my mind. Like HZvalentine said, this guy is a pro (and so is PK). He didn't make these decisions lightly, and I trust his judgement. Think about who we're dealing with here. PB, along with AC as a whole, is notorious for practically never playing a song the same way twice. We never should have expected this album to cater to our tastes, or make things easy. Hell, we were even outright warned:
Expect the Unexpected.
How many of us on this forum have had the experience when an AC album 'clicked' for you? I would expect every last one of us has experienced that. Before that moment happens, the album can be difficult to listen to, but that doesn't mean it's a failure. It's been less than 48 hours since this freebirded, so I think it's safe to say our impressions are still not fully formed.
For those who aren't enjoying the album, I don't want to say you're wrong, since everyone is entitled to their opinion. I also acknowledge the fact that some people may never fully enjoy the album, plain and simple. But I do encourage anyone who didn't like it to give the album a second (or third...or fourth...) chance and really trust PB on this one, because I think he's going places where no musician's gone before.