[superspookyghost]

hatredcopter wrote:

My contrarian take is that MPP slander - or not even slander, just criticism - or not even criticism! just ambivalence - is a contrarian take. MPP is obviously their best album, obviously one of THE best albums, it’s an unimpeachable work of art, a life-changing and astonishing listen to this day, and pointing out its “flaws” or even just saying “not my cup of tea” is as bonkers as like, going to the Grand Canyon and saying “not deep enough” or “not for me.”

I really and truly wish I could feel that way about MPP.

[Stories and Games]

cookies and cream is a vastly overrated ice cream flavor

[Collected Animals]

Painting With vocals are the pop version of the vocals on Campfire Songs

[tdegenaro]

Seasonal comment: “slasher flicks” is the best avey tare solo joint

[foxtrot]

that is a hot take for sure.

[roopn]

Honeycomb, Gotham or Crimson wouldn't have made a meaningful improvement to Chz's tracklist, which doesn't need improving anyway

[superspookyghost]

roopn wrote:

Honeycomb, Gotham or Crimson wouldn't have made a meaningful improvement to Chz's tracklist, which doesn't need improving anyway

All 3 of those songs are astronomically better than Rosie Oh.

[dansemanatee]

superspookyghost wrote:

roopn wrote:

Honeycomb, Gotham or Crimson wouldn't have made a meaningful improvement to Chz's tracklist, which doesn't need improving anyway

All 3 of those songs are astronomically better than Rosie Oh.

Definitely agree but I like chz the way it is. honeycomb/gotham works really well as a single and crimson backs applesauce nicely.

wish there was at least one 2011 boot with taste that sounded good. Crimson into taste is so great

[Fovrodi]

Gotham<NTB<Monkey Riches<Honeycomb<Mercury Man<crimson<pulleys would’ve fuckin ripped

[foxtrot]

Centipede Cursed:

1. Honeycomb
2. Today's Supernatural
3. Gotham
4. Mercury Man
5. NTB
6. Monkey
7. Wide Eyed
8. Father Time
9. Rosie Oh
10. Crimson

[meys]

superspookyghost wrote:

roopn wrote:

Honeycomb, Gotham or Crimson wouldn't have made a meaningful improvement to Chz's tracklist, which doesn't need improving anyway

All 3 of those songs are astronomically better than Rosie Oh.

No, they just royally fucked up Rosie in the studio

[hypo's]

superspookyghost wrote:

hatredcopter wrote:

My contrarian take is that MPP slander - or not even slander, just criticism - or not even criticism! just ambivalence - is a contrarian take. MPP is obviously their best album, obviously one of THE best albums, it’s an unimpeachable work of art, a life-changing and astonishing listen to this day, and pointing out its “flaws” or even just saying “not my cup of tea” is as bonkers as like, going to the Grand Canyon and saying “not deep enough” or “not for me.”

I really and truly wish I could feel that way about MPP.

same, studio version is mids (worst xmas ever!)


and the og comment here can eat fart, you're being silly, fart eater!

[tdegenaro]

Hash wrote:

Person Pitch is the only Panda Bear album that's even close to being as good as Down There.

hash idk if you're around here that much anymore but just so you know this is CRAZY. Eucalyptus is unlistenable compared to Buoys and that's PB's weakest record by a lightyear.

[destiny]

[qute"tdegenaro"][qute="Hash"]
Person Pitch is the only Panda Bear album that's even close to being as good as Down There.[/quote][/quote]


hash idk if you're around here that much anymore but just so you know this is CRAZY. Eucalyptus is unlistenable compared to Buoys and that's PB's weakest record by a lightyear.[/quo

U made me so mad i purposely broke your quote to make my post look like an eyesore

[dansemanatee]

Eucalyptus is significantly better than buoys imo but yea person pitch is the only pb album that i love as much if not more than down there, but down there is incredibly special to me in a lot of ways and i still love the rest of pbs discog, even buoys though admittedly i think i still need to spend some more time with it.

but can u fr tell me boat race comes anywhere close to anything on buoys

[Tropic]

The best song on bouys (Crescendo) is a sister song to Boat Race, and would not exist without it

[dansemanatee]

Tropic wrote:

The best song on bouys (Crescendo) is a sister song to Boat Race, and would not exist without it

I am now even more inclined to spend more time with buoys

[destiny]

nothing on buoys comes close to season high or when u left me tbf...

[Dallou]

I allost never listen to it but Life bouys and homies era was the best of all time. Those songs slapped to much

[tdegenaro]

panda bear plays bouys was an exceptional tour but i'm still giving it to greaper, those shows were a whole other level. 1,000,000/10 experience.

[Hellomark]

Not the biggest fan of how Master turned out on the album, but it sounded amazing in the initial boots. Wish it would have kept that long droning piano outro.

[organic cat]

upset by how many of you misspell buoys

[destiny]

2018 pre-buyos shows are my fav panda era hehe, he sounded so fucking good

[roopn]

Agreed homies/buoys era PB was untouchable

[preakness]

I agree that MPP is definitely an amazing album, but also can agree the hype surrounding it kind of ignores how good the previous 4 albums were. It's a work of art, but I honestly think I have spent much more time listening to Feels and SJ than MPP.

I think Eucalyptus is far better than Down There, and his Eucalyptus tour dates were some of the best live Avey performances I've seen. Saying PP is worse than Down There is crazy.

Person Pitch is a perfect album IMO, and few releases, AC or otherwise, can touch it.

Also, I think Rosie Oh is a banger. Why don't people like the studio version? Is it the strange instrumentation? The mix is too busy?

[meemo]

Rosie Oh is my favorite studio track off of Centipede Hz.