Page 1 of 2

Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Wed Jan 21, 2015 11:45 pm
by roopn
List every song in an album in order from favourite to least favourite! hopefully some discussion could come out of it, who knows?
It's going to be tough

Centipede Hz:
1. Moonjock
2. Wide Eyed
3. New Town Burnout
4. Rosie Oh
5. Applesauce
6. Monkey Riches
7. Father Time
8. Pulleys
9. Today's Supernatural
10. Amanita
11. Mercury Man

(ps I know ratings are stupid, but it's fun anyway also don't hate on anybody's opinion)

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Wed Jan 21, 2015 11:58 pm
by jfw7
roopn wrote:
hopefully some discussion could come out of it

lol

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 12:31 am
by roopn
I can dream
:lol:

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 12:42 am
by hatredcopter
1. moonjock = yes

I have a theory. a theory that we can discuss! any AC song that's in 7/8 is the best song on whichever album it's on.

for example, Rev Green on SJ.
Moonjock on CHz.
WWIW?S on FBK.
what are the other 7/8 songs, I forget.

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 1:38 am
by sertman
ok ill bite

MPP:
1.) Brother Sport
2.) Bluish
3.) In The Flowers
4.) Daily Routine
5.) My Girls
6.) Taste
7.) Summertime Clothes
8.) Lion in a Coma
9.) Guy's Eyes
10.) No More Runnin
11.) Also Frightened

Feels:
1.) Banshee Beat
2.) Grass
3.) Purple Bottle
4.) Turn into Something
5.) Did You See the Words?
6.) Loch Raven
7.) Daffy Duck
8.) Bees
9.) Flesh Canoe

Person Pitch
1.) Bros
2.) Good Girl/Carrots
3.) Search for Delicious
4.) I'm Not
5.) Take Pills
6.) Comfy in Nautica
7.) Ponytail

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 1:41 am
by faded arrow
hatredcopter wrote:
I have a theory. a theory that we can discuss! any AC song that's in 7/8 is the best song on whichever album it's on.

no

I'll just do MPP and C.Hz for now. They change all the time

C.Hz
1. Applesauce
2. Monkey Riches
3. Amanita
4. Today's Supernatural
5. New Town Burnout
6. Moonjock
7. Rosie Oh
8. Father Time
9. Mercury Man
10. Pulleys
11. Wide Eyed

sorry deak

MPP
1. Brother Sport
2. My Girls
3. Bluish
4. Guys Eyes
5. Summertime Clothes
6. Lion In A Coma
7. Also Frightened
8. In The Flowers
9. No More Runnin
10. Taste
11. Daily Routine

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 1:42 am
by yunginternet
No. Title Lead vocals Length
1. "Easier" Rossen 3:43
2. "Lullabye" Droste/Rossen 5:14
3. "Knife" Droste 5:14
4. "Central and Remote" Droste 4:54
5. "Little Brother" (lyrics by Fred Nicolaus) Rossen 6:24
6. "Plans" Droste 4:16
7. "Marla" (co-written by Marla Forbes) Droste 4:56
8. "On a Neck, On a Spit" Rossen 5:46
9. "Reprise" Rossen 3:19
10. "Colorado" Droste 6:14
11. "Granny Diner" (Japanese release only) Rossen 4:51
Personnel[edit]

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 1:43 am
by yunginternet
"Eruption" – 1:42 (Michael Anthony, David Lee Roth, Eddie Van Halen, Alex Van Halen)
(from Van Halen, 1978)
"Ain't Talkin' 'bout Love" – 3:47 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from Van Halen, 1978)
"Runnin' with the Devil" – 3:32 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from Van Halen, 1978)
"Dance the Night Away" – 3:04 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from Van Halen II, 1979)
"And the Cradle Will Rock..." – 3:31 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from Women and Children First, 1980)
"Unchained" – 3:27 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from Fair Warning, 1981)
"Jump" – 4:04 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from 1984, 1984)
"Panama" – 3:31 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from 1984, 1984)
"Why Can't This Be Love" – 3:45 (Anthony, Sammy Hagar, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from 5150, 1986)
"Dreams" – 4:54 (Anthony, Hagar, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from 5150, 1986)
"When It's Love" – 5:36 (Anthony, Hagar, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from OU812, 1988)
"Poundcake" – 5:22 (Anthony, Hagar, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge, 1991)
"Right Now" – 5:21 (Anthony, Hagar, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge, 1991)
"Can't Stop Lovin' You" – 4:08 (Anthony, Hagar, Van Halen, Van Halen)
(from Balance, 1995)
"Humans Being" – 5:14 (Anthony, Hagar, Van Halen, Van Halen)†
(from Twister soundtrack, 1996)
"Can't Get This Stuff No More" – 5:16 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)†
(new song, 1996)
"Me Wise Magic" – 6:09 (Anthony, Roth, Van Halen, Van Halen)†
(new song, 1996)

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 2:05 am
by New Zealand
no pedro stop

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 2:14 am
by roopn
Yellow house is so good

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 3:36 pm
by jetski
Do Veckatimest next

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 8:32 pm
by HowardTJMoon
PBVGR

1. Tropic of Cancer
2. Crosswords
3. Mr Noah, Boys Latin
4. Come to your senses
5. Principe Real
6. Davy Jones' Locker, Shadow of the Collossus
7.
8.
9.
10
11.
12.
13. Butcher Baker Candlestick Maker, Sequential circuits, lonely wanderer, selfish gene, acid wash.

STGTTV

1. Alvin Row
2. Bat You'll Fly
3. April and the Phantom, Untitled, Chocolate Girl, Everyone Whistling, La Rapet, SiGtBaTatG

Here Comes the Indian

1. Infant Dressing Table, Hey Light, Native Belle, Slippi, Two Sails on a Sound, Too Soon

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Thu Jan 22, 2015 8:46 pm
by faded arrow
FBK
1. Graze
2. I Think I Can
3. What Would I Want? Sky
4. On A Highway
5. Bleed

SJ
1. Fireworks
2. Derek
3. Winter Wonderland
4. Chores
5. Peacebone
6. Reverend Green
7. #1
8. Unsolved Mysteries
9. Cuckoo Cuckoo

Feels
1. The Purple Bottle
2. Banshee Beat
3. Turn Into Something
4. Loch Raven
5. Grass
6. Did You See The Words
7. Daffy Duck
8. Flesh Canoe
9. Bees

Person Pitch
1. Bros
2. Take Pills
3. Good Girl / Carrots
4. Comfy In Nautica
5. Ponytail
6. I'm Not
7. Search For Delicious

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Fri Jan 23, 2015 2:54 am
by roopn
Other music boot:
1. Untitled
2. On a Plain
3. Happy Singing Band
4. Covered in Frogs
5. Winters Love
6. Untitled warm-up song
7.. Baby Day
8. Learning How to dive
9. Lablakely Dress

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Fri Jan 23, 2015 7:32 pm
by coollodges
Chumbawumba-Tubthumper

Image

Amnesia
Drip, Drip, Drip
The Big Issue
The Good Ship Lifestyle
One by One
Outsider
Creepy Crawling
Mary, Mary
Smalltown
I Want More
Scapegoat
Tubthumping

great album but the title track never really did it for me.

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Fri Jan 23, 2015 10:08 pm
by hatredcopter
fadedarrow wrote:
hatredcopter wrote:
I have a theory. a theory that we can discuss! any AC song that's in 7/8 is the best song on whichever album it's on.

no

expand on that

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Fri Jan 23, 2015 10:40 pm
by kafkaesque
SJ

1. Fireworks
2. Unsolved Mysteries
3. Cuckoo Cuckoo
4. Reverend Green
5. Peacebone
6. Chores
7. #1
8. Derek
9. Winter Wonder Land

^ incredibly difficult, amazing album

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 12:14 am
by Losercore
1.Daily Routine (the best anco song ok)
2.Bluish/Summertime Clothes
4.Brother Sport
5.In the Flowers
6.No More Runnin'
7.My Girls
8. Also Frightened
9. Guys Eyes
10.Lion in a Coma
11.Taste

1.Fireworks
2. FRG
3.#1
4.Peacebone
5.Derek
6.Cuckoo Cuckoo
7.Chores
8.Unsolved Mysteries
9.winter wonder land

1.Loch Raven
2.Banshee Beat
3.The Purple Bottle
4.Did You See the Words?
5.Daffy Duck
6.Bees
7.Flesh Canoe
8.Grass(idk how this ended up so low)
9.Turn into Something

Wow feels is really hard to do.

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 2:36 am
by yunginternet
Image
Track listing[edit]
All lyrics written by Lou Reed, all music composed by Reed and Metallica.

Disc one
No. Title Length
1. "Brandenburg Gate" 4:19
2. "The View" 5:17
3. "Pumping Blood" 7:24
4. "Mistress Dread" 6:51
5. "Iced Honey" 4:36
6. "Cheat on Me" 11:26
Disc two
No. Title Length
7. "Frustration" 8:34
8. "Little Dog" 8:01
9. "Dragon" 11:08
10. "Junior Dad" 19:29
Total length:
87:05

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 2:38 am
by roopn
Keep tape:
1. The Preakness *sweats*
2. Country Report
3. Call Home (Buy Grapes)
4. Jailhouse

... Sorry Geo, it's still a good intro

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 3:10 am
by roopn
Collages - Windy City Mirage

1. Frat Haus
2. Hello Home
3. Aimlessly Spiralling
4. Datamine
5. Moussey
6. Time Crimez
7. Stoop kid
8. Way of the wind
9. Strangers Came from Light
10. Cognitive Resonance

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 10:35 am
by rocks
I find this sort of thing hard to do. I was gonna do CHZ but I really love them all except maybe moonjock not so much.
I'll do FBK
1. Sky
2. On a Highway
3. I Think I Can
4. Graze
5. Bleed

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 11:16 am
by roopn
I never really got the fuss over on a highway. I'll do FBK.

1. Sky
2. I think I Can
3. Graze
4. Bleed
5 on a highway

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 4:07 pm
by popadam
mbv - loveless
1. to here knows when
2. only shallow
3. when you sleep
4. soon
5. sometimes
6. loomer
7. i only said
8. come in alone
9. what you want
10. blown a wish
11. touched

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 4:12 pm
by rocks
why is loomer so low on your list?

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 4:26 pm
by Marshmallow People
Campfire Songs:

1. Do Soto De Son
2. Queens in my Pictures/Doggy
4. Moo Rah Rah Rain
5. Two Corvettes

Incredibly hard thing to do because I usually play the whole album through. De Soto De Son was never in question of being number 1 though, and QIMP/Doggy go so well together I wasn't able to separate them.

But yeah, overall, a perfect album IMO.

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sat Jan 24, 2015 10:02 pm
by coollodges
Spoiler: show
roopn wrote:
Collages - Windy City Mirage

1. Frat Haus
2. Hello Home
3. Aimlessly Spiralling
4. Datamine
5. Moussey
6. Time Crimez
7. Stoop kid
8. Way of the wind
9. Strangers Came from Light
10. Cognitive Resonance

hey thanks this is interesting to see!

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 12:08 am
by popadam
rocks wrote:
why is loomer so low on your list?

bc i like 5 songs on the record more than it right now. i dont think it grows as much as the songs i put ahead of it or does as much sonically or melodically that i like.. but still i fucking love every song on that album

another list:
radiohead - kid a
1. idioteque
2. the national anthem
3. how to disappear completely
4. kid a
5. motion picture soundtrack
6. everything in its right place
7. optimistic
8. in limbo
9. morning bell
10. treefingers

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 2:20 am
by conswaygo
MPP:
1.) Brother Sport
2.) In The Flowers
3.) Bluish
4.) Daily Routine
5.) Guy's Eyes
6.) Taste
7.) Summertime Clothes
8.) Lion in a Coma
9.) No More Runnin
10.) My Girls
11.) Also Frightened

Feels:
1.) Purple Bottle
2.) Banshee Beat
3.) Loch Raven
4.) Did You See the Words?
5.) Grass
6.) Flesh Canoe
7.) Turn Into Something
8.) Bees
9.) Daffy Duck

Person Pitch
1.) Good Girl/Carrots
2.) Bros
3.) Take Pills
4.) Comfy in Nautica
5.) Ponytail
6.) Search for Delicious
7.) I'm Not

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 2:22 am
by roopn
coollodges wrote:
Spoiler: show
roopn wrote:
Collages - Windy City Mirage

1. Frat Haus
2. Hello Home
3. Aimlessly Spiralling
4. Datamine
5. Moussey
6. Time Crimez
7. Stoop kid
8. Way of the wind
9. Strangers Came from Light
10. Cognitive Resonance

hey thanks this is interesting to see!

I've been jammin your album for days man, I love every minute :flail:

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 2:34 am
by faded arrow
hatredcopter wrote:
fadedarrow wrote:
hatredcopter wrote:
I have a theory. a theory that we can discuss! any AC song that's in 7/8 is the best song on whichever album it's on.

no

expand on that

lol

I'm a four-on-the-floor kinda guy

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 2:50 am
by roopn
popadam wrote:
Spoiler: show
another list:
radiohead - kid a
1. idioteque
2. the national anthem
3. how to disappear completely
4. kid a
5. motion picture soundtrack
6. everything in its right place
7. optimistic
8. in limbo
9. morning bell
10. treefingers

1. Everything in its Right Place
2. The National Anthem
3. In Limbo
4. Morning Bell
5. Optimistic
6. Idioteque
7 . Kid A
8. How to disappear completely
9. Treefingers
10. Motion Picture Soundtrack

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 8:02 am
by William H. Macy
pbvsgr

lone wanderer
sequential circuits
tropic of cancer
mr noah
butcher baker
principe real
boys latin
acid wash
crosswords
selfish gene
come to your senses

really loved ctys on the earliest boots, back when it sounded like he was sampling a vacuum cleaner. og principe was killer too

crosswords was one of my favs before, but i really don't like how it just jumps in now. not a fan of the super processed robot vocals in the background either.

i'm surprised at the lack of love for circuits, i think it's tied with wanderer for me

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 8:42 am
by roopn
fucken love seq circ. Crosswords was a song I never really got the hype for, but now that I listen to the album it's definitely the grooviest, it's grown on me for sure.
I'm not completely sure on this list, but here we go:

PBVSGR
1. Crosswords
2. Sequential Circuits
3. Butcher Baker Candlestick Maker
4. Acid Wash
5. Principe Real
6. Come to Your Senses
7. Selfish Gene
8. Tropic of Cancer
9. Mr Noah
10. Lonely Wanderer
11. Boys Latin

I'm kinda sad Boys latin ended up so low, it was the first one that was really exciting to me in the boots but now maybe because it was a single I'm just kind of over it

and for good measure:
Mr Noah EP
1. Faces in the Crowd
2. This side of Paradise
3. Mr Noah
4. Untying the Knot

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 4:33 pm
by roopn
Atlas Sound - Logos

1. Quick Canal (w. Laetitia Sadier)
2. Sheila
3. Attic Lights
4. Walkabout (w. Noah Lennox)
5. Kid Klimax
6. The Light That Failed
7. Washington School
8. An Orchid
9. Criminals
10. My Halo
11. Logos

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 4:54 pm
by jetski
Listening to this a ton lately
Dettinger - Oasis
1. Oasis 3
2. Oasis 1
3. Oasis 5
4. Oasis 4
5. Oasis 6
6. Oasis 7
7. Oasis 2

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 4:57 pm
by popadam
pb.vs.gr + ep
1. selfish gene
2. come to your senses
3. loney wanderer
4. tropic of cancer
5. faces in the crowd
6. acid wash
7. sequential circuits
8. garage
9. mr noah
10. principe real
11. boys latin
12. untying the knot
13. this side of paradise
14. butcher baker candlestick maker

couple other anco relases...

stgstv
1. alvin row
2. chocolate girl
3. la rapet
4. april and the phantom
5. penny dreadfuls
6. spirit they've vanished
7. untitled
8. bat you'll fly
9. someday ill grow
10. everyone whistling

feels
1. banshee beat
2. the purple bottle
3. loch raven
4. did you see the words
5. flesh canoe
6. grass
7. turn into something
8. daffy duck
9. bees

strawberry jam
1. fireworks
2. for reverend green
3. cuckoo cuckoo
4. #1
5. peacebone
6. derek
7. winter wonder land
8. unsolved mysteries
9. chores

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 5:07 pm
by MFpotus
Crosswords
Mr Noah
Butcher Baker Candlestick Maker
Selfish Gene
Come to Your Senses
Principe Real
Boy's Latin
Tropic of Cancer
Sequential Circuits
Acid Wash
Lonely Wanderer

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 5:19 pm
by faded arrow
1. Tropic of Cancer
2. Crosswords
3. Mr Noah
4. Butcher Baker Candlestick Maker
5. Selfish Gene
6. Come To Your Senses
7. Boys Latin
8. Acid Wash
9. Lonely Wanderer
10. Principe Real
11. Sequential Circuits

Re: Rate the songs in an album!

Posted: Sun Jan 25, 2015 9:43 pm
by IkoOvo
roopn wrote:
1. Everything in its Right Place
2. The National Anthem
3. In Limbo
4. Morning Bell
5. Optimistic
6. Idioteque
7 . Kid A
8. How to disappear completely
9. Treefingers
10. Motion Picture Soundtrack

motion picture soundtrack was one of the first songs to make me go :negative: