Page 3 of 5
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Sun Sep 11, 2022 11:09 pm
by Hellomark
Dragon Slayer 12 (-)
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 12
Cherokee 22 (+)
Passer-by 8
We Go Back 9
Royal and Desire 14
If I'm being real, I think Cherokee and Strung are by faaar the best songs on here, and Cherokee just has the edge cause I associate it with all the different live versions.
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Sun Sep 11, 2022 11:41 pm
by ITS OK CITRUS
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 12 (-)
Strung with Everything 12
Cherokee 23 (+)
Passer-by 8
We Go Back 9
Royal and Desire 14
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Mon Sep 12, 2022 5:53 am
by rohcti
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 12
Strung with Everything 12
Cherokee 23
Passer-by 8
We Go Back 10 (+)
Royal and Desire 13 (-)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Mon Sep 12, 2022 6:06 am
by foxtrot
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 12
Strung with Everything 13 (+)
Cherokee 23
Passer-by 7 (-)
We Go Back 10
Royal and Desire 13
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Mon Sep 12, 2022 6:17 am
by tay's tee games
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13 (+)
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 23
Passer-by 7
We Go Back 10
Royal and Desire 12 (-)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 12:02 am
by jiraiya
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 23
Passer-by 8 (+)
We Go Back 9 (-)
Royal and Desire 12
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 12:25 am
by Slippi's Applesauce
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 23
Passer-by 9 (+)
We Go Back 8 (-)
Royal and Desire 12
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 2:44 am
by denjanenna
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 24 (+)
Passer-by 9
We Go Back 7 (-)
Royal and Desire 12
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 3:07 am
by Dusty
Dragon 12
Prester 13
Strung 13
Cherokee 24
Passerby 8 (-)
We Go Back 7
Royal 13 (+)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 6:39 pm
by captainlunatic
Dragon 12
Prester 13
Strung 12 (-)
Cherokee 24
Passerby 8
We Go Back 8 (+)
Royal 13
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 6:43 pm
by awesome
Dragon 12
Prester 13
Strung 12
Cherokee 24
Passerby 7 (-)
We Go Back 8
Royal 14 (+)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 7:32 pm
by Dusty
Dragon 12
Prester 13
Strung 12
Cherokee 24
Passerby 6 (-)
We Go Back 9 (+)
Royal 14
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 8:09 pm
by scrambledgreggs
Dragon 12
Prester 12 (-)
Strung 12
Cherokee 24
Passerby 6
We Go Back 10 (+)
Royal 14
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 9:37 pm
by Slippi's Applesauce
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13 (+)
Strung with Everything 12
Cherokee 24
Passerby 6
We Go Back 9 (-)
Royal and desire 14
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 13, 2022 11:16 pm
by captainlunatic
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 11 (-)
Cherokee 24
Passer-by 7 (+)
We Go Back 9
Royal and desire 14
now i'm mr. passer-by
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Wed Sep 14, 2022 12:43 am
by jiraiya
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 11
Cherokee 24
Passer-by 8 (+)
We Go Back 8 (-)
Royal and desire 14
another day of slowly chipping away at we go back while defending passer-by. cmon passer-bys, we got this
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Wed Sep 14, 2022 12:45 am
by rohcti
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 11
Cherokee 24
Passer-by 8
We Go Back 9 (+)
Royal and desire 13 (-)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Wed Sep 14, 2022 4:20 pm
by denjanenna
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 11
Cherokee 25 (+)
Passer-by 8
We Go Back 8 (-)
Royal and desire 13
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2022 5:25 am
by foxtrot
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 12 (+)
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 7 (-)
We Go Back 8
Royal and desire 13
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2022 8:52 pm
by jiraiya
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 12
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 8 (+)
We Go Back 7 (-)
Royal and desire 13
>:(
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Thu Sep 15, 2022 11:17 pm
by TonyPajamas
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 12
Cherokee 24 (-)
Passer-by 8
We Go Back 8 (+)
Royal and desire 13
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2022 12:53 am
by foxtrot
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13 (+)
Cherokee 24
Passer-by 7 (-)
We Go Back 8
Royal and desire 13
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2022 12:57 am
by real slippi
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 25 (+)
Passer-by 6 (-)
We Go Back 8
Royal and desire 13
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2022 2:42 am
by awesome
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 5 (-)
We Go Back 8
Royal and desire 14 (+)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2022 3:04 am
by denjanenna
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 26 (+)
Passer-by 5
We Go Back 7 (-)
Royal and desire 14
I see your zany shenanigans TonyPajamas…
Unrelated note: I’m curious if everybody keeps their votes consistent. Even if a song is inevitably about to die, I’ll still take a point from my actual least favorite, even if it’s one that’s still going strong. I’ve seen some just kill a song they haven’t been deducting in previous rounds just to keep the game rolling and I feel like soils things in a small way.
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2022 6:14 am
by BoomCheese
I used to keep my votes consistent, as I also liked a clear-cut game where we vote on favourite vs. least favourite, but now I like to vote based on context. For example, if a mid song like Cherokee racks up heaps of points I'll bump it down, or if one of my favourite songs (but not absolute favourite) is getting dooted on (e.g. Passerby), I'll bump it up. I think this makes the game more unique and tactical. Otherwise, the game is not much different to a poll.
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 13
Cherokee 25 (-)
Passer-by 6 (+)
We Go Back 7
Royal and desire 14
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2022 2:35 pm
by hankmcspanky
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 13
Strung with Everything 14 (+)
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 5 (-)
We Go Back 7
Royal and desire 14
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Fri Sep 16, 2022 11:30 pm
by TonyPajamas
denjanenna wrote:
I see your zany shenanigans TonyPajamas…
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2022 11:03 pm
by Dusty
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 14
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 4 (-)
We Go Back 7
Royal and desire 15 (+)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Sun Sep 18, 2022 11:46 pm
by Slippi's Applesauce
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 14
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 5 (+)
We Go Back 6 (-)
Royal and desire 15
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2022 12:22 am
by jiraiya
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 14
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 6 (+)
We Go Back 5 (-)
Royal and desire 15
oh nooo!!!!
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2022 3:06 am
by FAF
Dragon Slayer 12
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 14
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 5 (-)
We Go Back 5
Royal and desire 16 (+)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2022 11:48 am
by disengaged
Dragon Slayer 13 (+)
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 14
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 4 (-)
We Go Back 5
Royal and desire 16
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Mon Sep 19, 2022 2:14 pm
by partario
Dragon Slayer 14 (+)
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 14
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 3 (-)
We Go Back 5
Royal and desire 16
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2022 1:05 am
by foxtrot
Dragon Slayer 14
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 15 (+)
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 2 (-)
We Go Back 5
Royal and desire 16
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2022 12:42 pm
by jiraiya
Dragon Slayer 14
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 15
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 3 (+)
We Go Back 4 (-)
Royal and desire 16
lmao the passer-by dream is nearly dead. probably my third fave on the album so i hate to see it go so early
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2022 1:21 pm
by MFpotus
Dragon Slayer 14
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 15
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 4 (+)
We Go Back 3 (-)
Royal and desire 16
If it's gotta go it's gotta go (after We Go Back)
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2022 1:30 pm
by awesome
Dragon Slayer 15 (+)
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 15
Cherokee 25
Passer-by 4
We Go Back 2 (-)
Royal and desire 16
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Tue Sep 20, 2022 2:14 pm
by denjanenna
Dragon Slayer 15
Prester John 14
Strung with Everything 15
Cherokee 26 (+)
Passer-by 4
We Go Back 1 (-)
Royal and desire 16
Re: Time Skiffs: here it is 11, there it is 19
Posted: Wed Sep 21, 2022 6:02 am
by tay's tee games
Dragon Slayer 15
Prester John 15 (+)
Strung with Everything 15
Cherokee 26
Passer-by 4
We Go Back 1
Royal and desire 15 (-)