Collected Animals

inspired by some of yals ideas mixed with looking at past couple eras of live sets to try and determine what old songs they decide to play im calling....

Feels rep: Turn into Something, maybe even jamming pretty hard on the outro at the end of a pre-encore set

SJ rep: Unsolved again or Street Fladh with slight chance of Winter Wonderland

Mpp rep: Chance of Flowers renewed for a 3rd season, small chance of Lion in a Coma or Bleed

Chz rep: ... unknowable, somehow doubt one, doubt Pulleys renewal.. Gotham?

PW rep: I think they're gonna keep waiting on that, like how there were no CHZ songs during PW tour

misc: Piggies or Bridge to Quiet possible, super rare possibility of Slippi, random CHZ pick

final call: Gotham, Turn into Something, Unsolved Mystery, Bleed, and Purple Bottle or Fickle Cycle again

small chance: Street Flash, Winter Wonderland, Lion in a Coma, Bridge to Quiet, Slippi, random CHZ pick

Seems like they’ve been pretty consistent about including at least one or two EP/single B-side cuts since at least CHz days — not that it’s necessarily intentional. Fickle Cycle could stay around and a fresh FBK track could suffice, but I’m holding out hope for something from Water Curses

But I’m thinking what they will do instead … is pull out Gnip Gnop!!!

For some reason I just really don't see a PW song coming up at all. But it'd be cool cuz it'd have to be a true "rework" since their set up is so different rn. I guess Panda would just be Jeremy while also singing and Avey would maybe put a big, squelchy filter on his bass?

Gotham a quietly obvious one

woah they should/could do Gotham !

Gotham and Cobwebs or Street Flash have been rattling around my brain — all seem like they’d fit this current kit super well

Strung With Everything

Gotham and Cobwebs or Street Flash have been rattling around my brain — all seem like they’d fit this current kit super well

Shoot meant to add Street Flash. Yeah I think Gotham and Street Flash make a lot of sense, they like picking slower tracks from mpp-ish era lately so why not. If Cobwebs came back during CHZ tour, surely Street Flash should happen

Crimson would be amazing too, if we're throwing Gotham out there.

I'm holding out for WWIWS and Street Flash. Would love to see Banshee beat opener come back from 2019 as well.


Yall think they're gonna keep Purp bot as the set finisher or swap it out for rev green/something else?

they've both come up in the past couple tours, so i'd rather they change it up with another classic. i want fireworks with a new middle deep cut inserted in

Kids on Holiday -> Cherokee

ooh kids on holiday could be good since i think it really shines in the live feels era

I'm holding out for WWIWS and Street Flash. Would love to see Banshee beat opener come back from 2019 as well.


Yall think they're gonna keep Purp bot as the set finisher or swap it out for rev green/something else?

tbh i didnt enjoy the old songs from sets from 2019 onwards rly at all . i dont liike the faithful versions

agree that I prefer the new interpretations a lot more (even though Bottle and Cycle rocked) but I think the faithful versions are more a product of this era's instrumentation -- Which is why a PW cut would be a lot of fun!

They should get rid of In the Flowers and do In the Singing Box

I could def do without In the Flowers. That's always going to be a studio song for me honestly.

All the other old ones from the past couple tours have been amazing to me though. Unsolved Mysteries into Gem and I is in Asheville one of my favorite boot moments ever.

i thought Flowers was pretty weak in the fall, yeah

It was fucking LOUD in '07, boots did not do it justice

Unsolved Mysteries into Gem and I is in Asheville one of my favorite boot moments ever.

hell yes. one of the most straight forward and effective transitions they've ever done. that drum beat

would love a return of Rev Green, Banshee Beat and/or Native Belle.

Could definitely see a jazzy, loungey WWIW?S working. Also Frightened would be a dream

Think it's pretty likely that a lot of the '19/'21 jams will be revisited (can see Grass, Fickle Cycle, Rev Green and maybe even Native Belle coming back). Interesting to me that none of the oldies from the new live era have been PB-led.

Hopes above all else from ones they haven't played in ages:

Applesauce (possible)
Amanita (possible)
Gotham (feels unlikely)
Graze (possible)
Also Frightened (possible)
Bluish (feels unlikely)
Safer (feels unlikely)
Street Flash (possible, good chance even)
Derek (possible - absolute dream)
Cuckoo Cuckoo (feels very unlikely)
Fireworks (could be time)
People (possible)
Turn Into Something (possible, good chance even)
Winters Love (feels unlikely)
We Tigers (feels unlikely)
Hey Light (feels very unlikely)
De Soto De Son (unlikely but actually think a full band Skiffified version would work super well)
Meet the Light Child (feels unlikely)
Penny Dreadfuls (zero chance)

Can't really see them bringing back any Sung Tongs stuff because of the '18 tour and don't see them doing anything PW era, or Ark/Hollind/Danse/Spirit chaos era unless it's Native Belle again. Could see them revisiting some stuff they did in the CHz era like DYSTW or Brothersport. Taste would be sweeeeet but they've done that the last two album cycles so I'll put that one to bed. Obviously Banshee would be out of this world but feel like they threw us a bone with that in '19 and may have put it back to bed for good.

I've now convinced myself that Peacemaker HAS to happen..

peacemaker would be amazing. i could easily see them throwing some swing on the rhythm and clicking it in with the skiffs stylings. probably the only song from PW besides on delay or maaaaaybe golden gal.

turn into something and la rapet are still my holdouts and hopes. noah's more textural drumming this era would be wonderful to see applied to la rapet since it also basically has the same mindset.

golden gal.

turn into something and la rapet

please

Can't really see them bringing back any Sung Tongs stuff because of the '18 tour

you're probably right but also i've suddenly got it in my head that the end of Car Keys would lead really nicely into the beginning of Leaf House so now i want that

Strange_Clams wrote:

I'm holding out for WWIWS and Street Flash. Would love to see Banshee beat opener come back from 2019 as well.


Yall think they're gonna keep Purp bot as the set finisher or swap it out for rev green/something else?

tbh i didnt enjoy the old songs from sets from 2019 onwards rly at all . i dont liike the faithful versions

p bear said he doesnt like playing old songs either. scrap it ac scrap it!!!!

This is why they need to put WWL in the gap between "the sun's no better off now!" and "let's tonight..."

A mellower, jaunty Grass would fit great, although I don't necessarily want that.

time seems right for a Monkey Riches revival

Alright so based on some AMA answers, no Winter Wonderland but maybe an ODDSAC jam?? Are we finally getting What Happened?

Also maybe Applesauce?? Brian said a favourite lyric of his was from it and he hadn't listened to it in ages until yesterday. Perhaps he'd be relistening to work out his parts before they start practicing?

It'll never happen, but a full band version of flight would be absolutely perfect for this era. Could transition to or from cherokee

Final predictions?

I feel like Fireworks is coming back, or I want to believe. Rosie Oh or Applesauce. Turn Into Something.

Unlikely wishes: Mr. Fingers, Safer, Tikwid, Hey Light, re-reworked Taste, Chocolate Girl

Final answer: Seal eyeing, Fireworks, Crimson and Turn into something.

Unlikely but wanted it since 2013: La Rapet

just gonna do one guess — man of oil (fingers crossed)

Turn into something really does feel inevitable, I hope we're all right!!! Seal eyeing or street flash is the dream, i really think I'd pass out in joy.
my probably-won't-happen pick is anything off of sung tongs but I'd love for em to prove me wrong!

just gonna do one guess — man of oil (fingers crossed)

YES PLS

La Rapet. Tikwid. Street Flash. Lion in a Coma. Gotham.

Definitely about time Fireworks showed up

They need to skiffsify Mercury Man. that would be a frenzy