Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2024 12:32 pm
by madameghostly
shamelessly stolen from an rym comment section
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2024 9:13 pm
by dansemanatee
madameghostly wrote:
shamelessly stolen from an rym comment section
not to be a hater but this is one of those songs that begs the question, did you even try not sounding like animal collective? i mean musically that sentiment speaks for itself, but even the title and what i am assuming is a bear of the panda variety on the cover. I started listening to it and i was like "yea ok this is definitely just someone who wanted to do their own take on ac" and then i skipped ahead a bit and he's literally just doing an avey impression.
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Sun Jan 07, 2024 9:15 pm
by dansemanatee
Was listening to this last night and the little part at 2:35 reminds me so much of avey and panda, gods widsom and lucy sound sm like both respectively
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Mon Jan 08, 2024 7:57 am
by scrambledgreggs
dansemanatee wrote:
madameghostly wrote:
shamelessly stolen from an rym comment section
not to be a hater but this is one of those songs that begs the question, did you even try not sounding like animal collective? i mean musically that sentiment speaks for itself, but even the title and what i am assuming is a bear of the panda variety on the cover. I started listening to it and i was like "yea ok this is definitely just someone who wanted to do their own take on ac" and then i skipped ahead a bit and he's literally just doing an avey impression.
honestly I don't mind other artists directly ripping off AC as long as they do it well, and this song is actually pretty good. just want more music that sounds like AC in my life
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 1:49 am
by grundletron3030
Hoping y'all can help me: I've been tryin to remember a band that released an album sometime around 2011- 2013 that felt very MPP-influenced. Reviews at the time noted the heavy influence/similarity. I can't for the life of me remember the band or album title, which suggests they may not have done much since. All I can remember is that the album cover had a vaguely floral theme - like maybe a painting of a bouquet or something like that? I remember enjoying the album and would like to give it another listen. Someone on here must know what I'm referring to...please help!
Thx in advance <3
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 1:54 am
by Fovrodi
Delorean? El Guincho?
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 2:12 am
by grundletron3030
Thanks for the suggestions. Unfortunately not either of those - altho I love Delorean and was obsessed with El Guincho when he released Alegranza. The parallels between that album and Person Pitch (and Strawberry Jam - swear I can hear a Fireworks sample in one of the songs) are uncanny.
Keep the suggestions coming!
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 4:24 am
by tulis
grundletron3030 wrote:
Hoping y'all can help me: I've been tryin to remember a band that released an album sometime around 2011- 2013 that felt very MPP-influenced. Reviews at the time noted the heavy influence/similarity. I can't for the life of me remember the band or album title, which suggests they may not have done much since. All I can remember is that the album cover had a vaguely floral theme - like maybe a painting of a bouquet or something like that? I remember enjoying the album and would like to give it another listen. Someone on here must know what I'm referring to...please help!
Thx in advance <3
New House - Burning Ship Fractal? Doesn't fit the album cover description, sorry
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 4:32 am
by Fovrodi
Rick Alvin/Alvin Band?
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 4:47 am
by grundletron3030
Neither of those - thanks again for trying to help me out. Think I am going to resort to scrolling through all Pitchfork reviews from 2011 - 2013. Will report back if/when I find it...
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 12:11 pm
by Alex Kintner
Caribou - Andorra?
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 22, 2024 7:00 pm
by scrambledgreggs
Sun Airway - Nocturne of Exploded Crystal Chandelier?
Pop Winds - The Turqoise?
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Sat Feb 24, 2024 6:33 pm
by unrecordednight
miniature tigers - fortress? cover is a painting and got compared to ac/panda bear in reviews i remember
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Sat Feb 24, 2024 11:05 pm
by Dallou
grundletron3030 wrote:
Hoping y'all can help me: I've been tryin to remember a band that released an album sometime around 2011- 2013 that felt very MPP-influenced. Reviews at the time noted the heavy influence/similarity. I can't for the life of me remember the band or album title, which suggests they may not have done much since. All I can remember is that the album cover had a vaguely floral theme - like maybe a painting of a bouquet or something like that? I remember enjoying the album and would like to give it another listen. Someone on here must know what I'm referring to...please help!
Thx in advance <3
I got you
song is a banger
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Mon Feb 26, 2024 1:59 am
by grundletron3030
Dallou wrote:
grundletron3030 wrote:
Hoping y'all can help me: I've been tryin to remember a band that released an album sometime around 2011- 2013 that felt very MPP-influenced. Reviews at the time noted the heavy influence/similarity. I can't for the life of me remember the band or album title, which suggests they may not have done much since. All I can remember is that the album cover had a vaguely floral theme - like maybe a painting of a bouquet or something like that? I remember enjoying the album and would like to give it another listen. Someone on here must know what I'm referring to...please help!
Thx in advance <3
I got you
song is a banger
YES! Dallou for the win - thank you!! I was about to conclude that I was imagining the whole thing. I scrolled thru years of Pitchfork reviews and even opened up my ancient macbook to browse my pre-streaming iTunes library to look for it to no avail. This song is indeed a banger. Thanks again, my brain can rest easy now.
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Feb 29, 2024 1:41 am
by dansemanatee
Early Drain Gang and early Black Kray sound like animal collective sometimes to me.
I Will Make You Bleed has always reminded me a lot of Person Pitch. Sometimes I wonder if PP had any sort of direct influence on Kray considering the way he uses samples and whatnot.
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2024 11:09 am
by Fovrodi
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2024 4:35 pm
by augustjsmith
Y'all ever fuck with Prussia? They were kind of a big deal on a local level in lower Michigan years and years ago. They never really broke out of the Detroit scene but they did make a couple great albums, and they were constantly drawing AnCo comparisons. They kind of sound like AnCo mixed with doowop or something.
Eventually they broke up and two of them formed the now-defunct group Jamaican Queens, which was similar but more abrasive, electronic, and pop.
To go a bit further, one of the main creative minds behind both these groups was part of another project out of Illinois, a more focused and straightforward country band called Ohtis, which still had whiffs of AnCo. Also made some great stuff.
Damn I love music.
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Fri Mar 01, 2024 6:25 pm
by scrambledgreggs
oh dang I love Jamaican Queens, need to check out Prussia then
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Sun Mar 03, 2024 9:49 pm
by augustjsmith
scrambledgreggs wrote:
oh dang I love Jamaican Queens, need to check out Prussia then
You'll enjoy! They were a lot closer to that 2000s indie sound than JQ. You can tell it was the era of Grizzly Bear et al. I wish Ryan (the singer of both bands) would do more stuff, his lyrics are unique.
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Wed Mar 27, 2024 8:44 pm
by Fritz
One could start a whole new thread of bands influenced by Animal Collective!
Three songs, one Skiffs-like from Caravan. There are even more Skiffs/IIN-like songs on this album, but this one has a dragon slayer, syncopated chord movement, and a gnarly set of keyboard/synth solos. There are Time Skiffs everywhere for those with ears to hear:
then also this piece of French psych pop i may have posted before I dunno it's cool. sounds like the exact same filter echo thing you'll find on 2004ish material:
and then the obvious Grateful Dead reference, haven't listened to this in a while and it's a well-known influence but a remarkably obvious precursor to Hollinndagain.
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Mar 28, 2024 1:12 pm
by Dallou
Fritz wrote:
One could start a whole new thread of bands influenced by Animal Collective!
Three songs, one Skiffs-like from Caravan. There are even more Skiffs/IIN-like songs on this album, but this one has a dragon slayer, syncopated chord movement, and a gnarly set of keyboard/synth solos. There are Time Skiffs everywhere for those with ears to hear:
then also this piece of French psych pop i may have posted before I dunno it's cool. sounds like the exact same filter echo thing you'll find on 2004ish material:
and then the obvious Grateful Dead reference, haven't listened to this in a while and it's a well-known influence but a remarkably obvious precursor to Hollinndagain.
that french album is sooo goood, I am pretty sur I discovered because someone (you?) posted it on the forum a while back
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Sat Apr 06, 2024 5:34 am
by dansemanatee
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Wed Apr 10, 2024 12:22 am
by scrambledgreggs
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Wed May 15, 2024 10:00 pm
by scrambledgreggs
I was bored at work so I made this rym guide to albums by lesser known contemporary bands that sound a lot like AC but are still good, and which specific album they sound like:
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Fri Jun 21, 2024 7:50 pm
by grundletron3030
Just stumbled across this guy on Bandcamp. Acoustic instrumental fingerpicking/ambient stuff. These two tracks give me jammy Sung Tongs/Visiting Friends vibes...
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Sep 05, 2024 12:51 pm
by lhtd
When I lived in northern Finland, in the Sami region, I found this artist, Nils-Aslak Valkeapää, whose joiks remind me of AC's "Pride and Fight" type of jams.
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Sep 26, 2024 5:32 am
by jfw7
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Sep 26, 2024 10:16 am
by Dallou
That's so sick and pretty
Re: Proto-AC: "this band/song sounds like Animal Collective"
Posted: Thu Nov 14, 2024 12:41 am
by Angelic Chaos
First thought hearing this track. The flangey vocals, the sparkly sounds. Come on.