Collected Animals

Prester John 9 (-)
Strung with Everything 11 (+)
Cherokee 13
Royal and Desire 7

Prester John 10 (+)
Strung with Everything 11
Cherokee 12 (-)
Royal and Desire 7

Prester John 10
Strung with Everything 10 (-)
Cherokee 12
Royal and Desire 8 (+)

Prester John 10
Strung with Everything 10
Cherokee 11 (-)
Royal and Desire 9 (+)



Someone do it. Please.

Prester John 10
Strung with Everything 10
Cherokee 10 (-)
Royal and Desire 10 (+)

THE PLAYING FIELD HAS BEEN LEVELLED

looks like a tie, wrap it up

looks like a tie, wrap it up

lol, yeah we're done here

also, those last 4 remaining would be a super solid EP in that exact order.

We did this before Skiffs even dropped with Skiffs 2 tracks as well (a poll, that is)

And Cherokee basically won/tied with Magicians, Sea of Light and Gem. So basically the tracks we're still waiting for. Maybe all of those have taken on mystical quality for a while when we learned Skiffs 1 tracklist.

But yeah yal its this to be clear:

1. Cherokee
2. Strung w/ Everything
3. Probably not quite Royal. incredible song but seems more like middle, maybe 4 or 5 best case scenario

My 3rd fave is probably Passerby or Prester... almost Dragon or Walker...

We did this before Skiffs even dropped with Skiffs 2 tracks as well (a poll, that is)

And Cherokee basically won/tied with Magicians, Sea of Light and Gem. So basically the tracks we're still waiting for. Maybe all of those have taken on mystical quality for a while when we learned Skiffs 1 tracklist.

But yeah yal its this to be clear:

1. Cherokee
2. Strung w/ Everything
3. Probably not quite Royal. incredible song but seems more like middle, maybe 4 or 5 best case scenario

My 3rd fave is probably Passerby or Prester... almost Dragon or Walker...

I like the idea of playing numbers game pre and post album release to measure demoitis. Guessing DS and Passerby ranked a lot higher

viewtopic.php?f=20&t=18838&start=80

meant to post it for comparison.

its the unreleased songs + Cherokee and interestingly Car Keys all tied

Always shocks me that people like gem and I so much. It’s cool and has the potential to hit pretty hard but I always saw it as way inferior to broke/strangers

^agree

No way Gem&I gave me chills seeing it live. Always been high on it.

Gem and I is somewhat deeply hugely better to me than Broke. So blessed I saw it live in Colorado

gem and I is fkn awesome but I would change my vote in that thread to genies if I could

between prester john, cherokee and royal & desire the top 3 on this album is STACKED